(Note: ECHL All-star game info prior to 2000 is incredibly hard to find, so this is likely incomplete)
| Player | Year | Team | Notes |
| Valicevic, Chris | 1994 | Greensboro Monarchs | |
| Parsons, Don | 1996 | Johnstown Chiefs | MVP |
| Valicevic, Chris | 1996 | Louisiana IceGators | |
| Rappana, Kevin | 1997 | Charlotte Checkers | |
| Valicevic, Chris | 1997 | Louisiana IceGators | |
| Valicevic, Chris | 1998 | Louisiana IceGators | |
| Bermingham, Jim | 1999 | Huntington Blizzard | |
| Hicks, Jamey | 1999 | Birmingham Bulls | |
| Obsut, Jaroslav | 1999 | Augusta Lynx | |
| Sirois, Allan | 1999 | Pee Dee Pride | |
| Thompson, Jamie | 1999 | Peoria Rivermen | |
| Valicevic, Chris | 1999 | Louisiana IceGators | |
| Lawmaster, Jason | 2000 | Peoria Rivermen | |
| Valicevic, Chris | 2000 | Louisiana IceGators | |
| Clark, Darren | 2001 | Peoria Rivermen | |
| Daubenspeck, Kirk | 2001 | South Carolina Stingrays | |
| Exner, Kenric | 2001 | Peoria Rivermen | |
| Hilton, Kevin | 2001 | Charlotte Checkers | |
| McCullough, Brian | 2001 | Richmond Renegades | |
| Stirling, Scott | 2001 | Trenton Titans | |
| Valicevic, Chris | 2001 | Louisiana IceGators | |
| Colley, Kevin | 2002 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| Sanford, Curtis | 2002 | Peoria Rivermen | |
| Sirois, Allan | 2002 | Pee Dee Pride | MVP |
| Colley, Kevin | 2003 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| Glumac, Mike | 2003 | Pee Dee Pride | |
| Henkel, Jim | 2003 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| McCullough, Brian | 2003 | Reading Royals | |
| Rennette, Tyler | 2003 | Peoria Rivermen | |
| Stirling, Scott | 2003 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | MVP |
| Fahey, Brian | 2004 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| McCullough, Brian | 2004 | Florida Everblades | |
| Stirling, Scott | 2004 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| Collins, Brian | 2005 | Pee Dee Pride | |
| Doyle, Frank | 2005 | Idaho Steelheads | MVP |
| Eberly, Danny | 2005 | Toledo Storm | |
| Wellar, Patrick | 2005 | Peoria Rivermen | |
| Hartlieb, Ernie | 2006 | Florida Everblades | Alternate captain |
| Moreland, Jake | 2006 | Stockton Thunder | |
| Rudkowsky, Cody | 2006 | Reading Royals | |
| Sisca, Daniel | 2006 | Florida Everblades | |
| Laliberte, John | 2007 | Trenton Titans | |
| Walsh, Tom | 2007 | Fresno Falcons | |
| Eizenman, Oren | 2008 | Fresno Falcons | |
| Yandle, Brian | 2008 | Phoenix Roadrunners | |
| Del Monte, Ryan | 2009 | Johnstown Chiefs | |
| Fornataro, Matt | 2009 | Phoenix Roadrunners | |
| Hemingway, Colin | 2009 | Alaska Aces | |
| Wilson, Michael | 2009 | Phoenix Roadrunners | |
| Bohmbach, Andy | 2011 | Toledo Walleye | |
| Langkow, Chris | 2011 | Alaska Aces | |
| Lizon, Erick | 2011 | Bakersfield Condors | |
| O’Hanley, Brian | 2011 | Cincinnati Cyclones | |
| Coetzee, Willie | 2013 | Toledo Walleye | |
| Moon, Nathan | 2013 | Evansville Icemen | |
| Urban, Denny | 2013 | Reading Royals | |
| Wrenn, William | 2013 | Alaska Aces | |
| Barnes, Tyler | 2015 | Toledo Walleye | |
| Brace, Riley | 2015 | Wheeling Nailers | |
| Crane, Chris | 2015 | Missouri Mavericks | |
| Bligh, Nick | 2017 | Adirondack Thunder | |
| Costello, Chad | 2017 | Allen Americans | |
| Sivak, Peter | 2017 | Alaska Aces | |
| Raskob, Willie | 2018 | Quad City Mallards | |
| Salituro, Dante | 2018 | Rapid City Rush | |
| Crane, Chris | 2020 | Wichita Thunder |
210Sports 