| Player | Year | Team | Notes |
| Tardif, Marc | 1996-97 | South Carolina Stingrays | |
| Hilton, Kevin | 1998-99 | Mississippi Sea Wolves | |
| Scott, Travis | 1998-99 | Mississippi Sea Wolves | |
| Boutin, J.F. | 1999-00 | Peoria Rivermen | IceCats ECHL affiliate; MVP |
| Clark, Darren | 1999-00 | Peoria Rivermen | IceCats ECHL affiliate |
| Lawmaster, Jason | 1999-00 | Peoria Rivermen | IceCats ECHL affiliate |
| Maloney, Darren | 1999-00 | Peoria Rivermen | IceCats ECHL affiliate |
| Razingar, Tomaz | 1999-00 | Peoria Rivermen | IceCats ECHL affiliate |
| Rudkowsky, Cody | 1999-00 | Peoria Rivermen | IceCats ECHL affiliate |
| Smith, Matt | 1999-00 | Peoria Rivermen | IceCats ECHL affiliate |
| Tremblay, Didier | 1999-00 | Peoria Rivermen | IceCats ECHL affiliate |
| Wasyluk, Trevor | 1999-00 | Peoria Rivermen | IceCats ECHL affiliate |
| Daubenspeck, Kirk | 2000-01 | South Carolina Stingrays | |
| Tremblay, Simon | 2001-02 | Greenville Grrrowl | |
| Colley, Kevin | 2002-03 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| Henkel, Jim | 2002-03 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| Moreland, Jake | 2002-03 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| Mougenel, Ryan | 2002-03 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| Stirling, Scott | 2002-03 | Atlantic City Boardwalk Bullies | |
| Beckford-Tseu, Chris | 2005-06 | Alaska Aces | |
| Maiser, Justin | 2005-06 | Alaska Aces | |
| Riddle, Troy | 2005-06 | Alaska Aces | |
| Wellar, Patrick | 2005-06 | Alaska Aces | |
| Bonneau, Jimmy | 2007-08 | Cincinnati Cyclones | |
| Starling, Chad | 2007-08 | Cincinnati Cyclones | Alternate captain |
| Campbell, Trent | 2008-09 | South Carolina Stingrays | |
| Wellar, Patrick | 2008-09 | South Carolina Stingrays | |
| Del Monte, Ryan | 2009-10 | Cincinnati Cyclones | |
| O’Hanley, Brian | 2009-10 | Cincinnati Cyclones | |
| Coleman, Gerald | 2010-11 | Alaska Aces | |
| Langkow, Chris | 2010-11 | Alaska Aces | |
| Salters, Leigh | 2011-12 | Florida Everblades | |
| Almeida, Barry | 2012-13 | Cincinnati Cyclones | |
| Gill, Riley | 2012-13 | Reading Royals | |
| O’Connor Ian | 2012-13 | Reading Royals | |
| Syner, T.J. | 2012-13 | Reading Royals | |
| Coleman, Gerald | 2013-14 | Alaska Aces | |
| Sivak, Peter | 2013-14 | Alaska Aces | |
| Trupp, Evan | 2013-14 | Alaska Aces | |
| Abeltshauser, Konrad | 2014-15 | Allen Americans | WorSharks ECHL affiliate |
| Arseneau, Vincent | 2014-15 | Allen Americans | WorSharks ECHL affiliate |
| Asuchak, Spencer | 2014-15 | Allen Americans | WorSharks ECHL affiliate |
| Costello, Chad | 2014-15 | Allen Americans | |
| Crane, Chris | 2014-15 | Allen Americans | |
| Gill, Riley | 2014-15 | Allen Americans | WorSharks ECHL affiliate |
| Hanson, Greger | 2014-15 | Allen Americans | WorSharks ECHL affiliate |
| Schwartz, Rylan | 2014-15 | Allen Americans | WorSharks ECHL affiliate |
| Arseneau, Vincent | 2015-16 | Allen Americans | |
| Asuchak, Spencer | 2015-16 | Allen Americans | |
| Costello, Chad | 2015-16 | Allen Americans | WorSharks ECHL affiliate; Captain |
| Gill, Riley | 2015-16 | Allen Americans | |
| Hanson, Greger | 2015-16 | Allen Americans | |
| McAdam, Eamon | 2018-19 | Newfoundland Growlers |
