| Player | Year | League | Team | Notes |
| Brauer, Bo | 2017-18 | B1G | Notre Dame | |
| Doremus, Daniel | 2013-14 | NCHC | Univ. of Denver | |
| Francis, Matt | 2008-09 | CHA | Bemidji State Univ. | |
| Heaphy, Shawn | 1988-89 | CCHA | Michigan State Univ. | |
| Heaphy, Shawn | 1989-90 | CCHA | Michigan State Univ. | |
| Helminen, Dwight | 2001-02 | CCHA | Univ. of Michigan | |
| Helminen, Dwight | 2002-03 | CCHA | Univ. of Michigan | |
| Henderson, Kevin | 2008-09 | CIS | Univ. of New Brunswick | |
| Macnee, Jack | 2017-18 | NEHC | Hobart College | DIII; Alternate captain |
| Marsh, Alec | 2016-17 | B1G | Penn State University | |
| Murray, Andrew | 2004-05 | CHA | Bemidji State Univ. | Captain |
| Raskob, Willie | 2016-17 | NCHC | Univ. of Minnesota-Duluth | |
| Saracino, Chris | 2009-10 | AHA | RIT | |
| Tennyson, Matt | 2011-12 | CCHA | Western Michigan Univ. | |
| Van Ryn, Mike | 1998-99 | CCHA | Univ. of Michigan | |
| Walters, Dane | 2011-12 | CCHA | Western Michigan Univ. | Alternate captain |
| Willick, Dylan | 2015-16 | CIS | University of New Brunswick | |
| Willick, Dylan | 2016-17 | USports | University of New Brunswick |
