| Player | Year | Team | Notes |
| Almeida, Barry | 2009-10 | Boston College | |
| Almeida, Barry | 2011-12 | Boston College | Alternate captain |
| Brennan, Michael | 2007-08 | Boston College | Captain |
| Burish, Adam | 2005-06 | Wisconsin | Captain |
| Carle, Matthew | 2003-04 | Denver | |
| Carle, Matthew | 2004-05 | Denver | |
| Ciampini, Daniel | 2013-14 | Union College | |
| Coleman, Jon | 1994-95 | Boston University | |
| Connolly, Mike | 2010-11 | Minnesota-Duluth | Alternate captain |
| Ferriero, Benn | 2007-08 | Boston College | |
| Florentino, Anthony | 2014-15 | Providence College | |
| Forrest, J.D. | 2000-01 | Boston College | |
| Guite, Ben | 1998-99 | Maine | |
| Keczmer, Dan | 1987-88 | Lake Superior State | |
| Kennedy, Tim | 2006-07 | Michigan State | |
| Lachance, Bob | 1994-95 | Boston University | |
| LaRose, Cory | 1998-99 | Maine | |
| Lerg, Bryan | 2006-07 | Michigan State | Alternate captain |
| McCarthy, John | 2008-09 | Boston University | |
| McKenzie, Jim | 2006-07 | Michigan State | |
| McKenzie, Kyle | 2014-15 | Providence College | |
| Michaud, Alfie | 1998-99 | Maine | |
| Monk, Josh | 2014-15 | Providence College | |
| O’Hanley, Brian | 2007-08 | Boston College | |
| Oleksuk, Travis | 2010-11 | Minnesota-Duluth | |
| Panzer, Jeff | 1999-00 | North Dakota | |
| Pavelski, Joe | 2005-06 | Wisconsin | |
| Pereira, Joe | 2008-09 | Boston University | |
| Petrecki, Nick | 2007-08 | Boston College | |
| Pohl, John | 2001-02 | Minnesota | Captain |
| Riddle, Troy | 2001-02 | Minnesota | |
| Sakellaropoulos, Alex | 2013-14 | Union College | |
| Saracino, Nick | 2014-15 | Providence College | |
| Thomas, Kyle | 2009-10 | Norwich University | Division III |
| Van Ryn, Mike | 1997-98 | Michigan | |
| Aveson, Lizzie | 2013-14 | SUNY-Plattsburgh | Division III/Women’s |
